Still Human: Finding Your Place in the Age of AI as a Mediator, Investigator, or Lawyer
Let’s be honest, most of us didn’t go into law, mediation, or workplace investigations because we wanted to compete with machines. We chose these professions because they are fundamentally human. They revolve around stories, nuance, emotion, conflict, and resolution. But lately, with all the chatter (and, let’s face it, pressure) around artificial intelligence, But lately, with all the chatter (and, let’s face it, pressure) around artificial intelligence, you may have found yourself wondering: Where do I fit into all of this? You’re not alone if you’ve felt a bit like the ground is shifting beneath your feet. From predictive analytics in HR to automated documentation tools, it feels like AI is knocking on every office door, including yours. And if you’ve built your career on reading people, resolving conflict, or untangling complex workplace dynamics, that can be deeply unsettling.
The truth is, it’s okay to feel conflicted. You can be curious and cautious at the same time. You can be fascinated by the possibilities while fiercely protective of the values that brought you into this work. It’s not about being anti-tech; it’s about being human-first. This moment isn’t about racing to catch up with AI. It’s about pausing to ask better questions, like how these tools might serve our clients, our ethics, and our own well-being without erasing the very heart of what we do.
The Algorithm Can’t Feel the Room
One of the most powerful tools you bring to your role, whether you're mediating a workplace dispute or conducting a sensitive investigation, is your ability to read the room. You notice what’s not being said. You pick up on body language, silences, and tone. You understand how trauma or power dynamics show up. AI can do a lot of things, but it cannot replicate your gut instinct when something feels off, or your ability to gently draw out the truth from someone who’s been silenced or afraid.
There’s also the matter of trust. People open up to people, not platforms. If someone is navigating a harassment claim, a wrongful termination, or a serious breakdown in workplace culture, they want to know they’re being heard by a real person, not fed into a system that will spit out a decision based on data points. Your presence, your voice, your judgment, they matter. More than ever, in fact, because as AI tools become more common, so does the need for trustworthy professionals who can navigate the gray areas that machines just don’t understand.
Of course, that doesn’t mean AI has no place in our work. Used thoughtfully, it can help us spot patterns, reduce administrative burdens, or even generate helpful insights. But it should never become a substitute for discernment, empathy, or the slow, careful thinking that our work so often requires. In a world that wants everything faster, you are one of the few people trained to slow things down, to listen before reacting, to consider all sides, and to protect fairness even when it’s inconvenient.
You’re Still the Safeguard, and That’s Not Going Away
In this AI era, there’s a temptation to believe that if something can be automated, it should be. But you and I both know that’s not always true. Just because AI can write a report or flag “risky” behavior doesn’t mean it should make the call on whether someone keeps their job. These decisions still require judgment. They require ethics. They require you.
Think about how often your work involves discretion. You don’t just follow policy, you interpret it. You don’t just apply precedent, you ask if it’s still fair in this situation, with these people, under these conditions. That kind of work will never be obsolete. In fact, as technology speeds things up, your role as a safeguard against injustice becomes even more important. You’re the one who says, Wait, let’s take a closer look. And that voice is needed now more than ever.
It’s easy to feel intimidated by AI, especially when every headline seems to announce the latest tool that will “revolutionize” your industry. But remember this: no matter how advanced these systems become, they’re still tools. They require context. They need oversight. And most of all, they depend on people like you to make sure they are used in ways that are responsible, respectful, and real. You’re not becoming obsolete, you’re becoming essential in a new way.
So, Where Do You Fit In? Right Here.
This is your reminder that you don’t have to have it all figured out. None of us do. Navigating the intersection of AI and human work is messy, evolving, and often contradictory. But your role is not disappearing, it’s evolving. The skills that make you good at what you do, listening, thinking critically, navigating emotion, and protecting fairness, are the very things that AI cannot replicate, and never will.
If you’re feeling unsure, that’s okay. But don’t disappear from the conversation. Stay curious. Ask questions. Push back when something doesn’t sit right. Learn what you can, and bring your voice to the table. Because if we want a future where technology serves justice, not the other way around, we need more professionals like you leading the way.
Subscribe to the newsletter and stay grounded, informed, and connected, right where you are. We offer practical insights and real talk about the increasingly AI-driven world.